[Translate to English:] La bandiera imperiale sventola al vento, il cielo è azzurro. Dietro di essa sventola la bandiera del Regno d'Italia.
The Nazi German Reich war flag and the war flag of the Kingdom of Italy together on the roof of the Villa Wolkonsky, site of the German embassy in Rome, summer 1943 © Bundesarchiv, N 1603 Bild-282 / Horst Grund

The end of an alliance

Summer 1943 was a decisive moment in the history of modern Italy, marking the beginning of the country’s long, arduous path from fascism to democracy. During these months, the deep military, political, economic, social, and moral crisis of the fascist regime and monarchy reached its high point. This period of growing rift between the Italian and German dictatorships—involving, above all, an erosion of the military-political alliance maintained during the years of shared war—was marked by crucial events and dramatic changes. 

By this time, the illusion of a brief, easily winnable war had long-since dispelled; failure on the various war-fronts had led to exhaustion with the military effort by a large portion of the Italian populace, including the army itself. The defeat of Italian troops in Russia in January 1943, the Axis capitulation in Tunisia the following May, and the Allied landing in Sicily on 10 July (Operation Husky), together deepened the fascist regime’s political crisis. It reached a culmination with Benito Mussolini’s arrest on 25 July and his replacement by Marshal Pietro Badoglio.

In the forty five days between Mussolini’s removal and, on 8 September, the announcement of the Allied-Italian armistice, the Italian government faced the task of managing the collapse of fascism within the country and continuing the war on Germany’s side. Rather than promoting national unity, the connected severe domestic repression intensified the country’s division.

In this situation, Marshal Badoglio's policies showed clear signs of indecision. While he demanded support from Germany and promised loyalty to the Axis powers, he simultaneously sent mixed signals to Britain and America about his government's true intentions. Despite pressure from Italy's democratic and anti-fascist parties to break away from Germany, Badoglio remained silent on the issue, keeping these parties uninformed of his plans.

Un folto gruppo di uomini e donne in abiti civili si trova sul ciglio della strada e guarda in direzione della telecamera.
Italian civilians in Parma or Reggio Emilia watching the passage of German troops (off camera), summer 1943 © US NARA, KB-Rottensteiner-047

Chronology of developments

In summer 1943, Allied bombardment of the Italian peninsula intensified. The war fought by Italy and Germany in Europe and Africa had now reached Italian soil, resulting in thousands of civilian casualties. Both the country’s artistic heritage and urban architecture suffered heavy damage. In addition to the large industrial cities and harbours, which had already been targeted by air raids, many historically significant urban centres also suffered damage. Monuments, churches, and civilian populations were gravely affected.

Most Italians saw the fascist regime as morally discredited, corrupt, and incapable of defending the country's interests. The military defeats, destruction of cities, and impoverishment of society increased this conviction. Only small groups of party functionaries and ‘war profiteers’ thrived in this situation. The alliance with Germany had come to be seen as the main impediment to peace, with Allied propaganda fuelling a resentment of the Germans that increased in the course of 1943.

The widespread chaos, violence, and destruction in Italian society during this period fundamentally changed relations between Germany and Italy. Following Mussolini's arrest on 25 July, German military presence in Italy increased dramatically - from a few thousand Wehrmacht and SS troops to approximately 195,000 within weeks. After the Allied landing in Sicily, Italy became a major theatre of war, where German forces would continue fighting until their final surrender on 2 May 1945.

The Wehrmacht's Propaganda Companies (Propagandakompanien) photographically documented these decisive events in Italy during the summer and autumn of 1943, leaving behind a crucial visual record.

Photo-reporters and soldiers: the propaganda companies

From the early days of their rise to power, the Nazis recognised the crucial role of propaganda in securing public support. After they came to power, they deployed new technical media, mainly radio, film, and photography, with a great deal of skill.
In Germany, photography had a long tradition. A highly modern form of photojournalism emerged in Germany in the 1920s, and the young Weimar Republic became one of Europe's leading centres for artistic photography. Once the Nazis were in power, most figures in the country’s artistic avant garde, including photographers, were forced to emigrate. 
Over the course of Nazi rule, the quality of photography deteriorated. There was a partial revival of late nineteenth-century traditional photography styles of photography; beyond this, propaganda-minister Joseph Goebbels exercised direct and very strict control over all areas of German artistic production—photography receiving special attention.

In 1938, on the verge of the Second World War, Goebbels’ ministry and the Armed Forces leadership agreed to establish military propaganda companies (PCs), largely composed of specialized personnel from different areas of journalism, art (in particular painters), and film (in particular cameramen and photographers).
In the war, the companies were active on all fronts. Many aspects of their work remain largely unknown. On the one hand the PCs offered the troops they accompanied newspapers, radio broadcasts, theatre, films, and variety-shows; on the other hand they collected and produced material used for propaganda purposes through the press, entirely under Nazi control. The main target audiences of this work were publications such as the well-known magazine Signal, published in several languages, and the ‘Deutsche Wochenschau’, broadcast in all the German-occupied countries. 
 

  • [Translate to English:] Un soldato guarda attraverso un telescopio. Un altro uomo è in piedi accanto a lui e guarda nella stessa direzione. Dietro di lui c'è un altro telescopio. Gli uomini si trovano sul tetto di un edificio, circondato da colline.
    A photographer of a propaganda company in an anti-aircraft gun position in Messina © BArch, N 1603 Bild-228 / Horst Grund
  • Tre uomini sono in piedi sul tetto di un edificio e indossano uniformi. Guardano attraverso telecamere e telescopi qualcosa al di fuori del bordo sinistro dell'immagine. In basso a sinistra c'è una città, a destra e sullo sfondo colline e campi.
    German photographers (among them Horst Grund) and cameramen belonging to a propaganda company in an anti-aircraft gun position in Messina © BArch, N 1603 Bild-258
  • [Translate to English:] Un'auto è nascosta dietro una casa, rami di pino sono attaccati alla parte anteriore e posteriore dell'auto come mimetizzazione. Un uomo in uniforme siede sui sedili anteriori e guarda in una grande telecamera montata su un treppiede. L'uomo dietro di lui non è in uniforme ed è in piedi sui sedili. Anche lui guarda attraverso una grande telecamera. I due guardano qualcosa sulla sinistra, all'esterno dell'immagine.
    Navy cameramen at work on a German military vehicle © BArch, N 1603 Bild-255
  • Un tedesco con un distintivo della Wehrmacht sul petto è seduto a un tavolo di legno davanti a una casa. Sta fumando. Davanti a lui c'è una macchina da scrivere, sta leggendo qualcosa. Sul tavolo c'è anche un libro con una rilegatura rossastra. Accanto c'è una specie di ciondolo ricoperto all'esterno da una rete di rami d'abete.
    The photographer and editor Horst Grund during work in Sicily © BArch, N 1603 Bild-244
  • Un militare si trova davanti a una casa, con una macchina fotografica in mano. La porta della casa è aperta, a destra della porta c'è un divano.
    A war correspondent on the Comiso airfield in front of a German headquarters building. A camera dangles from his left hand © BArch, Bild 101I-418-1845-19A / Wahner

Photo-archives

The photos shown here are kept in two archives. The first archive is the German Federal Archives in Koblenz, which offers online access to its database.(https://www.bild.bundesarchiv.de/dba/de/). Scholarly study and publication of photographs related to Italy began in the mid-1990s. Several photographs from the Bundesarchiv have since become iconic. A particularly large number of photographs document the events of summer 1943. This is partly due to the high survival rate of photographs from this period and partly because the disarmament of Italian forces and the occupation of Italy were significant events for German propaganda. The Koblenz archive primarily contains photos taken by Propaganda Companies (PK) accompanying units of the German Army and Air Force, while images related to the Navy and Waffen-SS are largely missing. Only about a third of the original material survived the war.

A second archival source is the US National Archives, which holds confiscated wartime materials. Among them are photographic negatives taken by military photographers embedded with SS units; these were later seized by Allied forces. Some of these images have been digitised and are available online , where they are organised by photographer name. Three collections of photographs are directly related to Italy: those attributed to Ferdinand Rottensteiner and Wolfgang Wiesebach, as well as some taken by Hermann Grönert. The first two collections date from the summer of 1943, while Grönert’s images come from early 1944 and document the fighting around the Allied landing at Anzio.

Literature

Bernd Boll, Das Bild als Waffe. Quellenkritische Anmerkungen zum Foto- und Filmmaterial der deutschen Propagandatruppe 1938-1945, in: Zeitschrift für Geschichtswissenschaft 54 (2006), no. 11, pp. 974-998.

Petra Bopp, Fremde im Visier. Fotoalben aus dem Zweiten Weltkrieg, Kerber Verlag, Bielefeld, 2009.

João Arthur Ciciliato Franzolin, ‘Die Wehrmacht’. Die offizielle Illustrierte Propagandazeitschrift der Deutschen Wehrmacht für das In- und Ausland (1936-1944), diss. Flensburg 2017, Flensburg, 2019.

Giovanni De Luna/Adolfo Mignemi (eds.), con la collaborazione di Carlo Gentile, Storia fotografica della Repubblica sociale italiana, Bollati Boringhieri, Turin, 1997.

Carlo Gentile, La Wehrmacht in Toscana. Immagini di un esercito di occupazione (1943-44), Carocci, Rome, 2006.

Jens Jäger, Propagandafotografie. Private Kriegsfotografie im Zweiten Weltkrieg, in: Visual History, 12 Feb. 2020, https://www.visual-history.de/2020/02/12/propagandafotografie/ 

DOI: https://doi.org/10.14765/zzf.dok-1727 (28 Aug. 2023).

Ángel Ruiz Kontara, Johannes Tanner – Bilder aus dem Zweiten Weltkrieg, in: Portal Militärgeschichte, 3 July 2023, URL: https://portal-militaergeschichte.de/kontara_bilder, DOI: https://doi.org/10.15500/akm.03.07.2023 (28 Aug. 2023).

Deutsch-Russisches Museum Berlin-Karlshorst (eds.): Propaganda-Fotograf im Zweiten Weltkrieg. Benno Wundshammer. Übersetzungen von Ekaterina Engel, Jennie Seitz. Ch. Links Verlag, Berlin 2014, ISBN 978-3-86153-815-8 (German, Russian).

Rainer Rutz, Signal. Eine deutsche Auslandsillustrierte als Propagandainstrument im Zweiten Weltkrieg, Klartext Verlag, Essen, 2007.

Rolf Sachsse, Die Erziehung zum Wegsehen. Fotografie im NS-Staat, Verlag der Kunst - Philo Fine Arts, Dresden, 2003.

Daniel Uziel, The Propaganda Warriors: The Wehrmacht and the Consolidation of the German Home Front, Peter Lang, Oxford/Berna, 2008.

Markus Wurzer, Disziplinierte Bilder. Kriegsbildberichterstattung im nationalsozialistischen Deutschland und faschistischen Italien im Vergleich, in: Visual History, 6 April 2020, https://www.visual-history.de/2020/04/06/disziplinierte-bilder-kriegsbildberichterstattung-deutschland-und-italien-im-vergleich/

DOI: https://doi.org/10.14765/zzf.dok-1742 (28 Aug. 2023)

Sommer 1943: Von Verbündeten zu Feinden

Authorship and translation

Author: Carlo Gentile

Image-research: Carlo Gentile and Elena Pirazzoli

Editing and layout: Elena Pirazzoli

Translated from German by: Joel Golb

© Project ‘The Massacres in Occupied Italy (1943-1945): Integrating the Perpetrators’ Memories’

2025

Text: CC BY NC SA 4.0

Image-research: Carlo Gentile, Elena Pirazzoli

Editing and layout: Elena Pirazzoli

Translation: Joel Golb 

Seitenanfang